The Polo Bar. Is it worth the hype?
A timeless NYC classic
Getting a reservation at The Polo Bar is still one of the hardest in NYC. Reservations open 30 days out, are only bookable via phone (and concierge services), and are often gone within minutes. Prime times are impossible to book, and even the non-prime ones are almost as difficult. So the question remains—does the experience justify the effort?
The Ambiance: Warm, Elegant, and Timeless
From the moment you step inside, you realize the hassle of booking was worth it. The restaurant is a tribute to classic America, with dark wood paneling, equestrian-themed artwork, and rich leather banquettes setting the tone. There’s no loud music, no over-the-top theatrics—just an effortlessly chic setting. Unlike other hyped NYC restaurants, The Polo Bar doesn’t rely on novelty. Instead, it leans into tradition, offering a space that feels warm, elegant, and timeless.
The service: Polished and Professional
Service is exactly what you would expect from place like this. Staff members are efficient, and highly attentive without being intrusive. Hospitality here feels genuine and seamless.
The Food: Elevated American Classics
Is The Polo Bar home to the best food in NYC? No. But is the food good? Absolutely. The menu is not about culinary innovation - it is all about American classics, prepared with high-quality ingredients and attention to detail, making for a meal that feels both indulgent and familiar. Some highlights:
Corned beef sandwich: Order it as a starter to have it cut into cubes. Rich and flavorful, it’s one of the best items on the menu, though best shared due to its richness.
Pigs in a blanket: A simple yet satisfying dish, featuring perfectly snappy sausages wrapped in buttery pastry.
The Polo Burger: it’s signature dish for a reason.
Desserts: you can’t go wrong with any of the desserts. I specially love the chocolate cake and the brownie. But, if you are fan of coconut, the coconut cake is a must try.
The restaurant also frequently offers a rotating special burger and other off-menu items. If it’s your first visit, stick with the classics. But if you’re a returning guest, the specials are worth exploring.
For those who appreciate classic New York dining, The Polo Bar delivers on atmosphere, service, and consistency. While it may not be the most groundbreaking meal in the city, it’s an experience like no other.